15 Former India Footballers Slam AIFF Chief Kalyan Chaubey

Fifteen former India footballers, led by Bhaichung Bhutia, have written to Union Sports Minister Mansukh Mandaviya urging immediate intervention to replace the All India Football Federation (AIFF) leadership, calling the state of Indian football "pathetic."
Dated November 17 ahead of AIFF executive committee elections on December 20, the letter blames president Kalyan Chaubey and his administration for a decline since taking office in 2022, The Shillong Times and Deccan Herald reported. Signatories including Renedy Singh, Deepak Mondal, Arindam Bhattacharya, Alvito D'Cunha, Harmanjot Singh Khabra, Anwar Ali, Dhanachandra Singh, Satish Bharti, Manjit Singh, Balwant Singh, Sehnaj Singh, Karanjit Singh, Harpreet Singh, and Baldeep Singh warned that keeping Chaubey for another term would delay revival by decades. They urged Mandaviya to appoint a leader carrying a proven track record to head the AIFF for the upcoming term, The Shillong Times reported. Before the letter, Bhutia said he had written to Chaubey and Deputy Secretary General M Satyanarayan asking how much was being paid for the friendlies and had received no reply, according to Times Now. AIFF members blocked Kalyan Chaubey's proposal to liquidate the federation's fixed deposit to pay debts from the Brazil, Uruguay, and Panama friendlies, referring the matter to AIFF Vice President NA Harris and the Executive Committee, according to Times Now.
Ranking Drop, Friendlies Row, And Club Shutdowns
The players said India's FIFA ranking had fallen from 95 to 138 in the three years since the current administration took over, Deccan Herald reported. They dismissed October's international friendlies against Brazil and Uruguay as a "publicity stunt" by a deficit-running federation, noting the games drew near-empty Kolkata crowds and cost India participation in the FIFA ASEAN Cup, while The Times of India added that payments to Brazil and Uruguay remain uncleared. The letter also blamed AIFF's failure to organize a proper domestic league for the shutdown of clubs such as Tata-owned Jamshedpur FC, leaving players without income or employment, and flagged the lack of a preparatory camp before the SAFF Championship in Dhaka, Deccan Herald noted. For the October 2026 Uruguay friendly in Kolkata, the AIFF cut ticket prices in selected blocks by 90% from Rs 1,999 to Rs 199, while the West Bengal government announced complimentary tickets for around 22,000 spectators, according to The Times of India. India's October 3, 2026 friendly against Brazil at Salt Lake Stadium drew an attendance of 51,402, leaving more than 33,000 seats unoccupied in the stadium's around 85,000 capacity, according to The Times of India. Hosting the three international friendlies against Brazil, Uruguay, and Panama put the AIFF in a financial deficit of 85-90 crores, with estimated match costs between Rs 80 crore and Rs 85 crore, according to Times Now.
Election Dynamics And SAFF Context
The Times of India noted that Chaubey, who beat Bhutia 33-1 in 2022, has lost backing in Gujarat and Daman & Diu, with Daman FA president Walter Pereira citing local political pressure. Deccan Herald reported that Chaubey is likely to enter the December 20 election as a Karnataka State Football Association candidate alongside NA Harris. Separately, The Shillong Times noted that although India's developmental squad beat Pakistan 2-1 in Dhaka on Tuesday to win a 10th SAFF Championship title with Suhail Ahmad Bhat winning the Golden Boot, the senior side suffered 5-0 and 3-0 defeats to New Zealand in November friendlies, arguing AFC Asian Cup knockout qualification and World Cup third-round qualifiers remain the true measure of progress. Former AIFF president Praful Patel is reportedly interested in contesting the December 2026 AIFF election again, while Bhaichung Bhutia stated he has no interest in contesting for the top post, according to National Herald.
