Pakistan Ship Manoeuvred Unsafely in INS Kolkata Collision: Navy Chief

Chief of Naval Staff Admiral Krishna Swaminathan said on Monday that Pakistan Navy vessel PNS Hunain manoeuvred unsafely and sustained significantly greater damage than Indian warship INS Kolkata during their September 15 collision in the North Arabian Sea, according to The Times of India. Speaking in New Delhi at the ANI National Security Summit 3.0, Swaminathan stated that the Pakistani vessel approached to a point of no return and hit the Indian ship while trying to veer away at the last instant.
September 15 North Arabian Sea Collision and 1991 Accord
Swaminathan said ships sometimes come close at sea in unfriendly competition, adding, "Luckily, it touched our ship in a position where we had no damage, but that ship had a lot more damage." He noted that the Pakistani vessel returned to port after the impact, while declining to comment on reports that PNS Hunain remains under repair more than two months later. Sources had earlier told The Times of India that INS Kolkata was on a routine surveillance mission when PNS Hunain approached at high speed and manoeuvred unsafely on the evening of September 15. Following the incident, India's Ministry of External Affairs summoned Pakistan's charge d'affaires to lodge a protest over the "unacceptable and unprofessional conduct" of Pakistani naval units. New Delhi contended that the encounter violated an April 1991 bilateral pact on advance notice of military exercises, specifically Article 10, which India said mandates a three-nautical-mile separation between naval vessels. The Times of India also noted a prior June 2011 collision in the Gulf of Aden, where Pakistan Navy ship PNS Babur brushed past Indian frigate INS Godavari while escorting MV Suez and damaged INS Godavari's helicopter net. Pakistan disputed India's account of the September 15 collision, accusing INS Kolkata of aggressive manoeuvres near PNS Hunain inside Pakistan's exclusive economic zone during its SEASPARK-26 naval exercise and lodging a counter-protest, according to the Times of India. Earlier in 2026, PNS Hunain rescued 18 foreign sailors from the Panama-flagged bulk carrier MV Gold Autumn and joined firefighting missions, according to The Week.
Remarks on U.S. Sinking of Iranian Warship
At the same summit, Swaminathan addressed the March sinking of an Iranian warship by a U.S. submarine days after the vessel attended India's International Fleet Review in Visakhapatnam in February 2026. Calling the episode an awkward situation for India because the fleet review promotes friendship and cooperation, he said India's engagement with the vessel had ended and it was sailing home in international waters outside Indian jurisdiction. Swaminathan stated the U.S. strike was not illegal under international maritime law because the United States and Iran were already at war, citing Second World War engagements across the Atlantic and Pacific oceans to note belligerents may strike adversaries outside an immediate theatre. However, he declined to assess whether the U.S. Navy's action was appropriate, saying that question rested with the U.S. Navy. The March 2026 U.S. sinking of the Iranian warship IRIS Dena prompted Indian opposition leader Rahul Gandhi to criticize Prime Minister Modi's silence, while former Foreign Secretary Kanwal Sibal said the U.S. ignored India's sensitivities, according to PBS News. The Iranian frigate IRIS Dena participated in the International Fleet Review and MILAN 2026 organized by the Indian Navy in Visakhapatnam from February 15 to February 25, 2026, before being torpedoed by a U.S. submarine off Sri Lanka in March, according to PBS News. The sinking was a rare instance of a submarine torpedoing a ship since World War II, according to PBS News.
